Doberman vs German Shepherd – Which Guard Dog Makes A Better Pet

Doberman vs German Shepherds are two of the most popular guard dogs today. They both have their advantages and disadvantages. There are many opinions about which one is better, but there isn’t much research done on it. I am going to share with you my opinion based on years of experience with these two breeds.

The Difference Between a Guard Dog And A Companion Dog:

A guard dog is a breed that was bred to protect its master from harm or attack. These dogs were originally used as watchdogs, but they have since been trained to work in a variety of other jobs such as search and rescue, police work, military service and even therapy animals.

Companion Dogs are those that are trained to serve humans in any way possible. Some examples include guide dogs for the blind or hearing dogs for the deaf.

In the case of Dobermans, they were bred to guard their masters. So when people say “guard dog” what they really mean is “companion dog”.

However, there are some differences between them. For example, a guard dog must be very strong and not easily frightened by anything. A companion dog may have certain physical characteristics that make him less likely to panic if scared.

The Difference Between A Doberman and A German Shepherd

There are several differences between a Doberman and a German Shepherd, but the first one you should be aware of is how they behave. While both are good guard dogs, you can distinguish them easily by their behavior when around strangers.

Both of these breeds are usually on the bigger side, but it’s the Doberman that tends to stand out more due to its sleek black coloring and distinctive mustache. The Doberman, contrary to popular belief, is not an aggressive breed. If anything, they are very loving towards their owners and even strangers. However, they will become aggressive if they sense any sort of potential threat. German Shepherds on the other hand have often been portrayed as villains in various movies. While this isn’t always true, they do tend to be more suspicious of strangers.

Both dogs are quite intelligent and can be trained relatively easily. This is mostly due to their strong desire to please their owners.

However, the general consensus is that the Doberman understands commands better than a German Shepherd Dog.

Health-wise, both of these breeds are prone to different diseases so be sure to buy pet insurance in case either gets sick. The average life span of a Doberman is between 10 and 11 years, while the German Shepherd lives on average between 10 and 12 years.

Again, the main difference here is weight. Dobermans weigh between 70 and 90 pounds when fully grown, while German Shepherds weigh anywhere from 55 to 65 pounds.

Other Differences Between A Doberman and A German Shepherd:

Doberman vs German Shepherd – Which Guard Dog Makes A Better Pet - Image

The Doberman Pinscher is originally from Germany and was bred originally as a watchdog, guard dog and sometimes hunting dog, although this use is now discouraged due to their aggressive behavior with other dogs. Used by the military in various tasks during World War II, nowadays this dog is mainly kept as a pet.

The German Shepherd Dog on the other hand was bred in Germany originally to herd sheep and protect the shepherd, although today they are widely kept as pets and also used as seeing-eye dogs. As a working dog it has extraordinary intelligence, stamina, agility and loyalty and was often referred to as the “superdog”.

There you have the main differences between a Doberman and German Shepherd Dog.

Sources & references used in this article:

Controlling canine hip dysplasia in Finland by M LeppaÈnen, H Saloniemi – Preventive veterinary medicine, 1999 – Elsevier

Breeding racism: The imperial battlefields of the “German” shepherd dog by A Skabelund – Society & Animals, 2008 –

German shepherds by FG Kern – 1990 –

DEVELOPMENT OF BREED PREFERENCE INDEX FOR PURE-BRED DOGS by R Raghy, D Sreekumar… – Indian Journal of …, 2019 –

Aggressive conflicts amongst dogs and factors affecting them by A Roll, J Unshelm – Applied animal behaviour science, 1997 – Elsevier